R/data_ison.R
ison_physicians.RdRon Burt prepared this data from
Coleman, Katz and Menzel's 1966 study on medical innovation.
They had collected data from physicians in four towns in Illinois:
Peoria, Bloomington, Quincy and Galesburg.
The four cities are held in one network, with each physician's city
as a node attribute.
No physician is in two cities, so there are no ties between cities.
to_subgraphs(ison_physicians, "city") returns the four networks.
Before version 2.5.0, this dataset was a list of the four networks.
Coleman, Katz and Menzel were concerned with the impact of network ties on the physicians' adoption of a new drug, tetracycline. Data on three types of ties were collected in response to three questions:
advice: "When you need information or advice about questions of therapy where do you usually turn?"
discussion: "And who are the three or four physicians with whom you most often find yourself discussing cases or therapy in the course of an ordinary week – last week for instance?"
friendship: "Would you tell me the first names of your three friends whom you see most often socially?"
Additional questions and records of prescriptions provided additional information:
recorded date of tetracycline adoption date
years in practice
(note that these are {messydates}-compatible dates)
conferences attended
(those that attended "Specialty" conferences presumably also attended "General" conferences)
regular subscriptions to medical journals
freetime spent associating with doctors
discussions, discussions on medical matters when with other doctors socially
clubs, memberships in clubs with other doctors
friends, the number of top 3 friends that are doctors
time practicing in current community
patients load (ordinal)
proximity, the physical proximity to other physicians (in building/sharing office)
medical specialty (GP/Internist/Pediatrician/Other)
the city where the physician practised
The physicians were interviewed with structured interviews 15 months after the drug was released. The month of adoption comes from the prescription records of the local pharmacies, not from the interviews.
data(ison_physicians)#> -- # Medical innovation --------------------------------------------------------
#> # A multiplex, directed network of 246 nodes and 310 friendship arcs, 480
#> advice arcs, and 309 discussion arcs
#>
#> -- Nodes
#> # A tibble: 246 x 13
#> adoption specialty conferences journals practice community patients freetime
#> <dbl> <chr> <chr> <dbl> <chr> <chr> <chr> <dbl>
#> 1 1 Pediatrici~ Specialty 9 1920..1~ 20+yrs 101-150 0
#> 2 12 GP None 5 1945.. -1yr 76-100 1
#> 3 8 Internist General 7 1935..1~ 10-20yrs 76-100 1
#> 4 9 GP General 6 1940..1~ 5-10yrs 51-75 0
#> 5 9 GP General 4 1935..1~ 10-20yrs 51-75 0
#> 6 10 Internist None 7 1930..1~ 10-20yrs 101-150 0.5
#> # i 240 more rows
#> # i 5 more variables: discussions <dbl>, friends <dbl>, clubs <dbl>,
#> # proximity <chr>, city <chr>
#>
#> -- Ties
#> # A tibble: 1,099 x 3
#> from to layer
#> <int> <int> <chr>
#> 1 1 8 friendship
#> 2 1 58 friendship
#> 3 1 87 advice
#> 4 1 90 advice
#> 5 1 110 advice
#> 6 1 112 friendship
#> # i 1,093 more rows
#>{networkdata}
Coleman, James, Elihu Katz, and Herbert Menzel. 1966. Medical innovation: A diffusion study. Indianapolis: The Bobbs-Merrill Company.
Coleman, James, Elihu Katz, and Herbert Menzel. 1957. "The diffusion of an innovation among physicians". Sociometry 20(4): 253-270. doi:10.2307/2785979